W1_S.Algheilani_Tuckman Assessment


 

 

1)      Problem definition

Takatuf introduced Project Management Development Program (Takatf14). The first week of the program was face to face intensive workshops. The program consists of members from different companies who barely knew each other. In order for this team to start the project and face the challenges, leadership style need to be decided and agreed by the team.

2)   Feasible alternatives

Tuckman (1965) discovered that teams normally go through five stages of growth: Forming, Storming, Norming and Performing. These stages are highly relevant to matrix teams since they may be highly diverse in culture [1].

tucman

Figure.1 Tuckman Model

Forming: In this stage, team members are introduced. They state why they were chosen or volunteered for the team and what they hope to accomplish within the team. Members cautiously explore the boundaries of acceptable group behavior. This is a stage of transition from individual to member status, and testing the leader’s guidance both formally and informally.

Storming: The team’s transition from the “As-Is” to the “To-Be” is called the Storming phase. All members have their own ideas as to how the process should look, and personal agendas are often rampant. Storming is probably the most difficult stage for the team. They begin to realize the tasks that are ahead are different and more difficult than they previously imagined. Impatient about the lack of progress, members argue about just what actions the team should take. They try to rely solely on their personal and professional experience and resist collaborating with some of the team members.

Norming: The Norming phase is when the team reaches a consensus on the “To-Be” process. Everyone wants to share the newly found focus. Enthusiasm is high, and the team is often tempted to go beyond the original scope of the process. During this stage, members reconcile competing loyalties and responsibilities. They accept the team, ground rules, roles, and the individuality of fellow members. Emotional conflict is reduced as previously competitive relationships become more cooperative.

Performing: By now the team has settled its relationships and expectations. They can begin performing by diagnosing, problem solving, and implementing changes. Team members have discovered and accepted other’s strengths and weakness. In addition, they have learned what their roles are.

 

3)      Developments of the outcomes of the alternative

In order for the team to identify in what stage they currently are. A survey to be conducted using Donald Clark [2].

The survey is used to determine in which stage the project fall. The following table represents the final results of the survey:

Name Forming storming Norming performing
A.AL-Abri 33 28 30 27
Asma 16 9 19 22
M.Al Mujaini 20 20 25 28
M.Al-Awaid 27 28 24 24
H.Al Zadjali 25 25 29 27
H.Albarrami 18 12 20 22
M.Al-Shaibani 24 20 26 32
S.Al amri 8 8 10 22
A.Al Azizi 23 21 25 29
H.Al Raisi 32 29  30 35
S.Algheilani 13 12 20 25
M.Hameed 23 24 22 27
M.AL Yaqoubi 23 18 25 27
H.Alamri 12 14 11 31
S.Al-Shehhi 17 12 20 26
T.Al Nabhani 21 27 20 23
K.Al-Shukaili 12 12 19 29
K.Al Maamari 14 10 20 23
M.Al Hasani 32 27 29 35
M.Al Rawahi 24 25 23 27
A.Al Jardani 22 24 20 28
S.Al Jabri 25 27 26 33
A.Hubais 24 18 20 22

Table.1 Donald Clark Team Survey for Takatf14

4)      Selection of the criteria

It is important to think about what future events may impact your project. The Delphi Technique is a method used to estimate the likelihood and outcome of future events [3]. Using Delphi Technique with P (90) for the results shown in Table.1.

Forming Storming Norming Performing
Min 8 8 10 22
Most likely 24 27 20 27
Max 33 29 30 35
Mean 23 24 20 28
St.Dev 4 3.5 3.3 2.2
P90 26 24 26 31

Table.2 Delphi Technique with P (90)

5)      Analysis and Comparison of the Alternative

It is Clear from Table.2 that the team in the Performing Stage. It also noticed that the first three stages’ readings are close to each other. This might give the project manager an idea that the team have some difficulties to move from the first three stages to the performing stage or that the answers that were given is not correctly answers to reflect the current progress of the project.

 

6)      Selection of the Preferred Alternative.

It is obvious from the results shown on Table.2 that the team is in the performing Stage.

 

7)      Performance Monitoring and the Post Evaluation of Result

Project Manager needs to enhance and make sure all the team’s members move to the current stage. He might conduct the survey periodically to check the progress and make sure that the members grow and perform at the same platform. By knowing the Team Progress and periodically check the progress will make a better understanding of the project and will help the team to mitigate any challenges and have a better understanding of the current states.

 

References

1)      Related Materials. (nd). Matrix Team. Retrieved from http://www.nwlink.com/~donclark/leader/leadtem2.html

2)     Related Materials. (nd). Leadership Style Survey. Retrieved from http://www.nwlink.com/~donclark/leader/survstyl.html

3)     Duncan Haughey. (nd). Delphi Technique a step-by-step Guide. Retrieved from http://www.projectsmart.co.uk/delphi-technique-a-step-by-step-guide.php

Advertisements

One thought on “W1_S.Algheilani_Tuckman Assessment

  1. Sorry Said, but while you did an acceptable job on your W1 blog itself, the two Don Clark citations are NOT appropriately formatted using APA format.

    NOW, if you had been working SMART, not HARD, you would have posted this early in the week and instead of NOT being able to claim credit for it, you would have had a RISK BUFFER to make the 10 minute corrections in order to get the 4 or 5 stars that this posting SHOULD have earned you had you cited it correctly.

    Lessons learned……..????

    BR,
    Dr. PDG, Boston, MA

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s